• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Blackwater Siren

Located in Key Largo, FL, Blackwater Siren is a tiki bar offering a diverse menu of American cuisine and seafood. With a focus on sustainability, the restaurant provides many vegetarian options and utilizes reusable tableware. The casual atmosphere, waterfront views, and friendly service make it an ideal spot for a meal with friends and family. Customers rave about dishes like the grilled grouper sandwich, mahi mahi, and spicy shrimp gazpacho. The house margarita is a must-try, while the coconut onion rings are a popular side. Blackwater Siren is a hidden gem worth exploring for a laid-back dining experience.

Blackwater Siren: Reviews & Ratings

Stacy S.
Stacy S.

Fun spot for lunch. Great service. Enjoyed a sandwich with grilled grouper and a cup of the spicy shrimp gazpacho. He had blackened grouper tacos, which were good - he would've preferred more blackened seasoning and no cheddar cheese. On a sustainability note, it would be great to only offer straws upon request and to stitch from a single-use plastic cup for tartar sauce to something reusable.

Roberta H.
Roberta H.

The food was good my meal (pasta with veggies) was really good! The mahi was good and we didn't love the onion rings. The atmosphere is nice it's a tiki bar on the water with great views. The server was friendly, helpful and funny! I enjoyed watching the sunset. Overall we would return. Our meal for 4 of us was $120. They add a 3% credit card fee. They do have a kids menu that is reasonably priced and it seems like they allow smoking because when we arrived it smelled like cigarette smoke. We had the mai tai and it was yummy! They had a cat around he was so sweet, and they do allow dogs.

Emily H.
Emily H.

Solid sandwich. I tried the mahi mahi and it was delicious. Also had the coconut onion rings which was also very good. Ambiance is super laid back and service was on point. Will be back.

William J.
William J.

This place isn't easy to find, but it's a worthwhile trip. It was a rainy day on our way to the Keys and my wife and I were looking for a place to have lunch. The staff was friendly and the service was good. The food was quite good and there was a good selection of beer and cocktails to choose from. There are also plenty of TVs to watch your favorite sports team on.

Nicki P.
Nicki P.

Came here for dinner on Saturday evening, it wasn't overly busy and was promptly seated in the back, screened in area near the water. Our waiter was friendly and accommodating. I ordered the house margarita and it was incredible!! Don't pass this one up! For my dinner, I ordered the mahi mahi sandwich with waffle fries. Very delicious! Cool spot right on the water, you can watch the boats passing through the canal while you eat!

Olaf N.
Olaf N.

My wife found the reviews here on Yelp and stopped here for lunch on our way out of the keys. We sat in the screened in outside upper patio alongside the dock by the 1/2 sunken boat. Rustic local bar and grill on bay side with friendly and fast service. We started with conch fritters and coconut onion rings that were excellent! Between all of us we had a tuna melt, pulled pork sandwich, tuna poke wrap and I had a great grilled grouper sandwich. All were fresh, well seasoned and tasted excellent! Recommend this place if you're on the way in or out of the keys. We will be back!! Note cash or debit cards are king as they do charge a 3% credit card fee.

Damn D.
Damn D.

Jalapeño poppers Onion rings Blue long islands Blackened Mahi Sandwich Clam Chowder Nice place to stop at , this is my 5th time here it has become my favorite spot to pass by on the way back to miami , nice place , good costumer service , prices are fair and the blue long islands HIT GOOD .

John R.
John R.

This is indeed a hidden gem. Depending on your navigation, you might end up back on the bridge and not under it just before getting to Key Largo to find this place. Thankfully, the road is pretty friendly if you make a mistake. Keep looking and you will find it. If you find the big tiki hut building with the sign saying they are closed on Tuesdays, you made it. They seem to cater to boat traffic quite a bit and service certainly has a local flare to it...when I ordered the Crazy Lady brew the waiter said, "oh, the crazy B..." Anyway... The food was surprisingly good. The Calamari - Lightly fried calamari served with savory marinara sauce was good, but the sauce could have been thicker. The Buffalo Shrimp panko breaded & tossed in hot sauce was a little light on the buffalo flavor, but that was okay. The Harvey Fish Sandwich - A Key Largo traditional favorite. Grilled Mahi with American cheese, tomato, & tartar sauce toasted on whole wheat. Yes, blackened for me, was outstanding. However, the real winner of the place was the frozen margaritas. Go figure that one! Come here, find the place, and have one - you will not be disappointed.

Location

As a food reviewer of the renowned tiki bar Blackwater Siren located in Key Largo, FL, I can attest to the unique and enjoyable dining experience this establishment offers. Owned by women, this divey yet casual spot brings together a mix of American and seafood cuisine, perfect for those looking to indulge in delicious meals by the water.

One of the standout features of Blackwater Siren is its sustainable practices, such as offering reusable tableware and focusing on eco-friendly initiatives like providing straws only upon request. This commitment to sustainability adds an extra layer of appeal to the dining experience.

Customer reviews rave about the delectable dishes, with favorites including grilled grouper sandwiches, blackened grouper tacos, and coconut onion rings. The mahi mahi dishes seem to be a crowd pleaser, with customers praising the flavors and quality of the seafood.

In addition to the scrumptious food, Blackwater Siren boasts a plethora of amenities such as outdoor seating, a full bar with happy hour specials, and even a pool table for entertainment. The laid-back ambiance and waterfront views make it a perfect spot for lunch, dinner, or even just enjoying a cocktail while watching the sunset.

If you're in the area and craving a memorable dining experience, Blackwater Siren is definitely worth a visit. With its diverse menu, friendly service, and charming atmosphere, this tiki bar is sure to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds.